Friday, July 11, 2008

Wanta know what we lost when our spineless Congress approved the FISA law?

Read what Chris Hedges has to say, via Kevin Drum:

This law will cripple the work of those of us who as reporters communicate regularly with people overseas, especially those in the Middle East. It will intimidate dissidents, human rights activists and courageous officials who seek to expose the lies of our government or governments allied with ours.

....The reach of such surveillance has already hampered my work. I was once told about a showdown between a U.S. warship and the Iranian navy that had the potential to escalate into a military conflict. I contacted someone who was on the ship at the time of the alleged incident and who reportedly had photos. His first question was whether my phone and e-mails were being monitored.

What could I say? How could I know? I offered to travel to see him but, frightened of retribution, he refused. I do not know if the man's story is true. I only know that the fear of surveillance made it impossible for me to determine its veracity.

Read more.

People, how much are we willing to give up to feel safe from terrorism? What will there be left to defend when we become just like the repressive governments we so proudly differentiate ourselves from?

"But we've never been attacked on our own soil before!"

Baloney. In the War of 1812, the British went so far as to burn down the White House. No one felt the need to bypass the constitution then. That's because it was still clear to Americans that what we had fought for in the first place was to be free from invasion of their privacy. The 4th Amendment was still fresh in their minds:

"The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonably search and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probably cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized."
Now we've allowed the government to not only invade our privacy without permission, but to do it without even telling us. They don't have to show probable cause, because it might help the terrorists. This means that right now, the government can wiretap the Obama campaign and find out everything that's going on there. (They already did this during the Kerry campaign, but now they can do it legally, so no one has to go to jail for it.)

Of course, if Obama is elected, he can also post government spies on his Republican opponents in the next election. This is not a partisan issue! This is about what it means to be an American.

We need to get a sense of perspective. For instance, five times as many people die each year from lack of health insurance (18,000) as did from terrorist attacks in the U.S. in the last decade. Where's the panicked rush to provide universal healthcare even if it means riding roughshod over our constitution?

According to experts, global warming is causing an extra 150,000 to 160,000 deaths a year worldwide already.

There's an easy cure for terrorism. It doesn't involve stripping U.S. citizens of their rights. No wars are necessary. No tougher immigration policies need to be enacted. All we have to do is behave honorably in the world.

When we stop supporting evil regimes (think Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Egypt, China, Burma, etc.) and stop overthrowing or meddling with popularly elected regimes (Venezuela, Iran in 1952, Guatemala in 1954 to name just a few) and stop supporting and arming terrorists when it's convenient for us (the Mujahideen in Afghanistan, contras in Nicaragua, even anti-Saddam terrorists in Iraq who later became anti-U.S. terrorists), our terrorism problems will vanish.

There are no terrorist attacks in Norway. That's because Norway sees its main international goal as making the world a better place. They use their vast oil wealth to better the lives of others, not support attacks against them.

Finally, when we throw the billions of dollars that now subsidize the oil and biofuels industries into a Manhattan-style research program for renewable energy, we will no longer need to compromise our principles to secure our oil supply. And it may help reduce the 150,000 to 160,000 deaths a year worldwide from global warming.

Instead of spying on our citizens, let's do something that will actually make a difference and show what a great country we are. This is what morality is all about.

Labels: , , ,

Friday, April 04, 2008

Mukasey's shameful lie about 9/11 prevention

A shocking story--not just because Mukasey lied, not just because he shed crocodile tears while lying, not just because he's using a lie to drum up support for illegal wiretapping when wiretapping in the case he describes was already legal, not just because it reveals that the Bush administration pointedly and deliberately ignored 9/11 warning signs--but above all because the story's not a screaming headline in the mainstream news. So here it is for my known readership of three.

Why Doesn’t the 9/11 Commission Know About Mukasey’s 9/11 Story?--CommonDreams.org

by Glenn Greenwald

Last week, during a question-and-answer session following a speech he delivered San Francisco, Attorney General Michael Mukasey revealed a startling and extremely newsworthy fact. As I wrote last Saturday, Mukasey claimed that, prior to 9/11, the Bush administration was aware of a telephone call being made by an Al Qaeda Terrorist from what he called a “safe house in Afghanistan” into the U.S., but failed to eavesdrop on that call. Some help is needed from readers here to generate the attention for this story that it requires.

In that speech, Mukasey blamed FISA’s warrant requirement for the failure to eavesdrop on that call — an assertion which is, for multiple reasons that I detailed in that post, completely false. He then tearfully claimed that FISA therefore caused the deaths of “three thousand people who went to work that day.” For obvious reasons, the Attorney Geenral’s FISA falsehoods themselves are extremely newsworthy, but it is the story he told about the pre-9/11-planning call from Afghanistan itself that is truly new, and truly extraordinary.

Critically, the 9/11 Commission Report — intended to be a comprehensive account of all relevant pre-9/11 activities — makes no mention whatsoever of the episode Mukasey described. What has been long publicly reported in great detail are multiple calls that were made between a global communications hub in Yemen and the U.S. — calls which the NSA did intercept without warrants (because, contrary to Mukasey’s lie, FISA does not and never did require a warrant for eavesdropping on foreign targets) but which, for some unknown reason, the NSA failed to share with the FBI and other agencies. But the critical pre-9/11 episode Mukasey described last week is nowhere to be found in the 9/11 Report or anywhere else. It just does not exist.

Yesterday, I contacted Lee Hamilton, the 9/11 Commission Vice Chairman, to ask him whether the Commission was ever told about Mukasey’s alleged Afghan Terrorist 9/11-planning telephone calls and/or the Bush administration’s failure/inability to eavesdrop on such calls. Hamilton refused to comment, first claiming that he was in meetings all day yesterday and had no time to talk to me. When asked if he would comment today or whenever he had time, he said he was not going to comment on this ever, since he had not read Mukasey’s speech. Calls to 9/11 Executive Director Philip Zelikow seeking comment were not returned and 9/11 Commission Chairman Tom Kean could not yet be reached.

It’s unacceptable for Hamilton to refuse to comment on Mukasey’s claims. The whole purpose of the 9/11 Commission was to ensure that there was full-scale investigation and disclosure of all facts relevant to the 9/11 attacks, including the Government’s actions and inactions in preventing that attack from occurring.

If the Attorney General of the United States, out of the blue, makes an extraordinary and new assertion in a public speech about an easy opportunity the Bush administration had to detect those attacks — an opportunity he claims was lost because of eavesdropping laws — Hamilton ought to say whether the Commission was ever told about this incident and/or whether Mukasey is telling the truth. Preventing high government officials from lying about the 9/11 attacks or exposing concealment of key 9/11 facts is his obligation as Vice Chairman of the Commission. Some type of comment from 9/11 Commission officials on Mukasey’s claims is vital for generating further attention to this story and for compelling Mukasey to account for what he said.

Hamilton is currently the President and Director of the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars, and director of The Center on Congress at Indiana University. Please email him at the address below, politely set forth the extraordinary claims the Attorney General just made about the 9/11 attacks (with citations to media sources about the speech — including here, here, and here), and urge him to fulfill his obligation as 9/11 Commission Vice Chair by confirming whether Mukasey’s revelations are true and/or were disclosed to the Commission during its investigation: Lee.hamilton@wilsoncenter.org.

This isn’t just a matter of academic and historical interest about the 9/11 attacks, although it is that. One of two things almost certainly happened here, each of which is of great importance. Either Mukasey is lying about the 9/11 attacks in order to manipulate Americans into believing that FISA’s warrant requirements are what prevented discovery of the 9/11 attacks and caused 3,000 American deaths — a completely disgusting act by the Attorney General which obviously cannot be ignored. Or, Mukasey has just revealed the most damning fact yet about the Bush’s administration’s ability and failure to have prevented the attacks — facts that, until now, were apparently concealed from the 9/11 Commission and the public.

Since I wrote about this on Saturday, there has been some slowly evolving media attention paid to it. On Monday, I discussed the story on the radio with Rachel Maddow who, as always, grasped completely its importance. The following night, she was on Countdown with Keith Olbermman, which had a lengthy and detailed segment, highlighting all of the right questions (video below). Raw Story compiled a very thorough article with the key facts, and the top Daily Kos post this morning does the same.

The great significance of this story — that Mukasey either completely fabricated a key 9/11 event or just revealed a heretofore unknown 9/11 bombshell — is self-evident and made clear by these growing accounts. Having Hamilton, Kean and/or Zelikow comment on the veracity of Mukasey’s claims about the 9/11 attacks — as they ought to do — is vital for advancing the story.

Glenn Greenwald was previously a constitutional law and civil rights litigator in New York. He is the author of the New York Times Bestselling book “How Would a Patriot Act?,” a critique of the Bush administration’s use of executive power, released in May 2006. His second book, “A Tragic Legacy“, examines the Bush legacy.

© Salon.com

Labels: , , ,